LIL'  JOSH SCANDALS:
From A.G. to Governor

Josh Shapiro’s handling of Pennsylvania’s clemency system has drawn growing criticism from criminal justice reform advocates, civil rights groups, and even members of his own party, who argue that he consistently prioritized political image over meaningful reform. Critics say Shapiro acted as a gatekeeper against second chances for rehabilitated inmates, particularly those serving life sentences, despite widespread calls to modernize Pennsylvania’s notoriously restrictive pardon system. His clashes with then-Lt. Governor John Fetterman exposed deep divisions over clemency policy, with Fetterman and reform advocates accusing Shapiro of being overly cautious, bureaucratic, and unwilling to take political risks on mercy and rehabilitation. The controversy intensified after reports revealed that many clemency recommendations approved by the Pennsylvania Board of Pardons remained unsigned during Shapiro’s tenure as governor, fueling accusations that he quietly stalled or obstructed releases while publicly presenting himself as a moderate reformer. To critics, Shapiro’s approach reflected a broader pattern of calculated political positioning designed to protect his national ambitions and avoid appearing “soft on crime,” even at the expense of people widely viewed as deserving a second chance. ​ ​